DESIGN AND MODELING

Scientific substantiation of a comprehensive assessment of the operational condition of highways based on the integration of diagnostic parameters

Authors

  • Aleksey A. Soldatov https://orcid.org/0009-0005-7911-4610 North-Caucasus Federal University, 355017, Stavropol, Pushkin Street, 1
  • Pyotr V. Rozhkov Stavropol Branch of MIREA – Russian Technological University, 355035, Stavropol Krai, Stavropol, Kulakov Avenue, building 8, in quarter 601
  • Yulia G. Lozikova North-Caucasus Federal University, 355017, Stavropol, Pushkin Street, 1
  • Sergey O. Yashin https://orcid.org/0009-0001-3784-8430 North-Caucasus Federal University, 355017, Stavropol, Pushkin Street, 1
  • Ivan A. Polezin North-Caucasus Federal University, 355017, Stavropol, Pushkin Street, 1

How to cite

GOST Soldatov A. A., Rozhkov P. V., Lozikova Y. G., Yashin S. O., Polezin I. A. Scientific substantiation of a comprehensive assessment of the operational condition of highways based on the integration of diagnostic parameters // STROITEL'NYE I DOROZHNYE MASHINY. 2026. Vol. 70. No. 10. P. 125-139. DOI: 10.25726/m4586-1324-0090-e
APA Soldatov, A. A., Rozhkov, P. V., Lozikova, Y. G., Yashin, S. O. & Polezin, I. A. (2026). Scientific substantiation of a comprehensive assessment of the operational condition of highways based on the integration of diagnostic parameters. STROITEL'NYE I DOROZHNYE MASHINY, 70(10), 125-139. https://doi.org/10.25726/m4586-1324-0090-e

Abstract

A comprehensive indicator of highway condition merges parameters measured by different instruments and regulated separately, so the outcome depends on the aggregation rule and on measurement error. The study substantiates the choice of this rule by the errors it makes in classifying road sections against regulatory requirements. A scenario model of 40,000 sections with category III limits was built, each described by roughness (IRI), rut depth, skid resistance and pavement strength coefficients. Monte Carlo simulation with a common deterioration factor and instrument errors compared power means of partial indices, from the minimum to the arithmetic mean, with a common regulatory threshold and with a threshold tuned for each rule on a calibration half of the network. With the common threshold, the arithmetic mean fails to detect 91.7% of non-compliances even under error-free measurement, while the minimum rule under instrument error yields 4.13% missed non-compliances, 7.43% false findings and the lowest total error of 11.56%; in 60.5% of its false findings the limiting parameter is the strength coefficient. After threshold tuning, the total error of the arithmetic mean remains 18.43%, against 11.17% for the minimum and 10.85% for the power mean of order −8. The model output indicates that compensatory aggregation is unsuitable for establishing compliance, which is better judged by the smallest partial index together with the limiting parameter; a softened minimum with a raised threshold gains little, and only when strength is measured with a large error.

Keywords

operational condition of highways road diagnostics comprehensive indicator International Roughness Index rutting skid resistance strength coefficient measurement error Monte Carlo simulation

Funding

The authors did not declare any external funding for this research.

References

Aleksandrov A.S., Semenova T.V. Method for calculating the limiting rut depth for safe traffic // Bulletin of the Siberian State University of Railway Transport. 2022. no. 1 (60). pp. 104-116.

Burtyl Yu.V., Kapskiy D.V. Modeling the relationship between smoothness and strength of flexible pavement structures based on theoretical and practical research // Bulletin of SibADI. 2022. vol. 19. no. 4. pp. 570-583.

Gorskiy M.Yu. On the effect of a non-deformable layer beneath pavement structures during testing with dynamic loading devices // Roads and Bridges. 2025. iss. 54. no. 2. pp. 92-108.

Elshami M.M.M., Tiraturyan A.N., Uglova E.V., Elgendi M.Z. Assessment of road pavement condition deterioration using artificial intelligence models // Advanced Engineering Research. 2022. vol. 22. no. 3. pp. 272-284.

Klyuev S.V., Slobodchikova N.A. A method for assessing the condition of roads // Bulletin of the School of Engineering of the Far Eastern Federal University. 2024. no. 4 (61). pp. 139-150.

Konorev A.S., Mironchuk S.A., Dumenko V.A., Volkov A.B. Investigation of methods for determining road pavement microprofile based on the results of comparative tests // Roads and Bridges. 2025. iss. 54. no. 2. pp. 78-91.

Perfilov A.S. The structure of the priority national project “Safe and High-Quality Roads” and the concept of the standard transport and operational condition of roads as fundamental to the project's initial structure // Repair. Restoration. Modernization. 2024. no. 7. pp. 3-12.

Podberezkin A.A. Investigation of uncertainty in multi-agent road pavement monitoring // Modeling, Optimization and Information Technology. 2026. vol. 14. no. 2 (53).

Slobodchikova N.A. Forecasting changes over time in certain variable parameters of road condition // Proceedings of Higher Educational Institutions. Investment. Construction. Real Estate. 2023. vol. 13. no. 4. pp. 677-686.

Tiraturyan A.N., Abdelaal M.E.R. Residual service life of pavement structures on roads with high traffic intensity // Modern Trends in Construction, Urban Planning and Territorial Planning. 2026. vol. 5. no. 2. pp. 97-106.

Abu Dabous S., Al-Khayyat G., Feroz S. Utility-based road maintenance prioritization method using pavement overall condition rating // The Baltic Journal of Road and Bridge Engineering. 2020. Vol. 15. no. 1. pp. 126-146.

Aleksikov S.V., Leskin A.I., Gofman D.I., Tregubova M.I. Dependence of longitudinal pavement roughness on the development of hidden roadway defects // Russian Journal of Building Construction and Architecture. 2026. no. 1 (69). pp. 99-107.

El Issaoui A., Feng Z., Lehtomäki M., Hyyppä E., Hyyppä H., Kaartinen H., Kukko A., Hyyppä J. Feasibility of mobile laser scanning towards operational accurate road rut depth measurements // Sensors. 2021. Vol. 21. no. 4. Art. 1180.

Jia X., Huang B., Dong Q., Zhu D., Maxwell J. Influence of pavement condition data variability on network-level maintenance decision // Transportation Research Record. 2016. Vol. 2589. no. 1. pp. 20-31.

Shamraeva V. Assessment of the transport and operational condition of roads based on mobile laboratory data using machine learning methods // Architecture and Engineering. 2025. Vol. 10. no. 1. pp. 89-102.

Metrics

13 views
0 downloads
Want to publish with us?
Submit an article

Similar Articles

<< < 1 2 3 4 5 6 

You may also start an advanced similarity search for this article.